Is France’s Ligue 1 truly football’s “Farmers League”?
Paris Saint-Germain’s dominance over the last decade has certainly earned the French top flight this nickname, but is it deserved? Why does Ligue 1 always catch so much flak? Why not the Bundesliga? Or the Scottish Premier League?
Join us as we tackle this head on, and dive deep into football leagues big and small from around the world, to find the most and least competitive football leagues on the planet.
In this video, we start by exploring the origins of the “Farmers League” term and why Ligue 1 is often labeled as such. With PSG winning 10 of the last 12 league titles, it’s easy to see why many fans think of France’s top division as uncompetitive. But what does “Farmers League” really mean? We break down the term to uncover its full implications, including how one team’s dominance over a league can lead to the perception of a lack of competition.
To determine if Ligue 1 is truly the least competitive league, we introduce the Farmers League Index (FLI), a formula designed to measure league competitiveness. The FLI considers various factors such as the ratio of title wins by the most successful team, the average margin of victory, and the average goal difference of the winning team.
I’ve analysed dozens of top flight leagues from around the globe, so you don’t have to, and put them through the GCSE-level maths formula, to reveal to you, the audience, just what are the least (and most) competitive leagues on the planet.
If you want more useless football analytics, make sure to check out my previous video; “Where is the toughest place to play on a Cold, Wet Tuesday night?” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I1y6aglUnEc
Route None is a new channel and as such we’d love your support. If you enjoy deep dives into football history and uncovering the stories behind events from football history, don’t forget to subscribe to stay updated with our latest content. Your support helps us grow and continue producing new videos on a regular basis.
source
Europeans: Promotions and Relegations makes the league Competitive!
Also Europe
– France, 1 Team keeps on winning
– England, Spain and Italy, 3 Teams keep on winning
– Germany, 1 Team keeps on winning
NBA not competitive Enough due to lack of relegations
– 8 Champions from 2019-2026
La liga is the best ❤
Amazing editing brother truly inspired by your style ❤🎉 best of luck 🤞🏼
Great video
what do you mean you are not good at math but after some tinkering came up with a crazy formula? i want to see reasoning for it so bad
.67 btw
Bayern is making Bundesliga boring, they unironically not just buy up the best players for their own roster, but also buy up even more talent for the bench and their b team just to make sure there is as little competition as possible against them.
Doing the FLI without Bayern in the League the Bundesliga would be at 1.82
Aside from England, can any league really say they are not a farmer's league? England usually has 3-4 competitive clubs that can go for the title. Otherwise it is at max 2-3 clubs and has always been. Ligue 1 in fact was unique prior to PSG's dominance. Which other league has its most successful team with just 10 League titles (okay PSG are now at 15)?
My perception of league football has been: Clubs who are utterly dominant domestically have a chance of winning in Europe. Prior to PSG, L1 didn't have that type of sustained dominance and it is evident in the European trophies L1 has.
Great video. Maybe also include the price/investment of the teams as a factor
That's a lot of leauges
You seem to get a step or two short of getting to the gist of the definition of "farmers league". Thus gave the video a -1 because without that understanding, all the rest of the exercise becomes pointless.
It's most probably connected to the video game phenomenon of "farming" — aggressively acquiring excessive amounts of some resource, usually by exploiting the game's weaknesses, — and a relevant term "farmer (or junior) team" which is an auxiliary team whose main purpose is to breed ("farm") talent for the main team.
The term thus refers to a situation when one team dominates a league financially so much that they are able to aggressively hoard all the top talent from other teams, even if they cannot make good use of it. So other teams have no hope of competing with them and their best bet is to get by by breeding and selling talent to the dominant team.
So the entire league effectively becomes "farmer teams" for the dominant team — thus the expression.
The key downside of this situation — and a rule of thumb of whether it's the case — is it fundamentally distorts the nature of the league and thus the dynamics of the games in it. It's no longer a competition for trophies or fans, it's a competition for the dominant team's recruiters' attention.
Oh boy, a look at leagues around the world!
proceeds to bin most leagues
In the Netherlands its between Ajax and PSV, few times between Feyenoord and PSV. Ajax has the higher reaches, and the lowest in between. PSV is more stable but unable in Europe.
The Dutch league is called the Mickey Mouse league, since we can't make a dent in Europe. Although it depends on who raines in that period, if its called the Mickey Mouse league.
After not winning 1 cup or championship for 5 years, ending 2nd behind Ajax, now we won 3 in a row. In a few years we will collapse, and Ajax will pick up again, for a few years. That's how it goes for about 40 years.
The problem with this system is that it doesn’t work for leagues where two teams dominate, like Barca and Real Madrid.
I think you're getting wrong the farmers league term. A farmer has to work a lot, so he wouldn't have time to play football in any serious matter outside important games.
Like, in 2012 and 2020, the Mirandés (a Tercera Division team, which in Spain at that time was actually the fourth Division) made it to semifinals of the Copa del Rey. Both times they were constantly interviewing the players, who all said that they could play football very little, since most of them were clerks, firefighters, teachers, policemen…and didn't play football professionally.
So yeah, I don't think farmer's league is a disrespect to farmers, more like an acknowledgement of how much they have to work.
It is not Methodology, the study of methods, but the easier word to say, wait for it, METHOD.
Can you do this for over the previous premier league eras? Like the 1950s or 1980s. And also for the championship
As a Bulgarian, I can confirm the Efbet Liga has not been very competitive in the last few years as Ludogorets won 14 consecutive titles, but they bottled the 2025/26 one.
It is not just about who wins the league. In the EPL any team can beat any other on any given day. Liverpool can rest 4 players before a big European game and be turned over at West ham. They can rest no players and still be turned over! It is the depth of competition week in week out that is the issue. The English top flight has always been the most competitive even before the creation of the EPL but now it also the richest league and the gap between itself and other leagues is growing ever wider. Seven different English teams have won the European Cup/Champions League versus just two from La Liga. Three other English teams have reached the final….including Leeds who were the victim of a bribed referee.
Jesus loves you repent he is coming back he died for your sins please ❤😊k
Celtic have now won 14 in 15 titles as of the 25/26 season. The BBC tried to big it up saying that because Hearts ran Celtic so close and Motherwell were also capable of beating the Old Firm, Scottish football is primed for a renaissance of sorts.
What they are overlooking though is both Celtic and Rangers had dire starts to the season. As both teams are in better places no it is seriously unlikely that will happen in 26/27, meaning Hearts will almost certainly not be in contention again. Motherwell looked like they might have been on the but have already lost their manager. BBC stated their 4 or 5 top players are tied down to contracts until 2028, but buggers clubs will not blink at buying out contracts with 2 years to run, so their team (and probably Hearts as well ) will likely will be picked apart in the summer.
So really just will be a continuation of the established order.
Scotland
Bayern won league 10 years in a row. Says it all
France L1 was more entertaining than Bundesliga or la Liga this year, yall are just hating
Germany looks like a farmers league, and for some years it definetly is, depends how good Bayern does xD but there is the second trophy Bayern isnt winning often in Germany – the German Cup – and while Bayern is financially just dominating and being finacially probably the best club world wide, the history of the cup is looking like that
2011–12 Borussia Dortmund
2012–13 Bayern Munich
2013–14 Borussia Dortmund
2014–15 VfL Wolfsburg
2015–16 Bayern Munich
2016–17 Borussia Dortmund
2017–18 Eintracht Frankfurt
2018–19 Bayern Munich
2019–20 Bayer Leverkusen
2020–21 Borussia Dortmund
2021–22 RB Leipzig
2022–23 Eintracht Frankfurt
2023–24 Bayer Leverkusen
2024–25 VfB Stuttgart