Andrew Wiebe breaks down the biggest and most controversial referee decisions from around Major League Soccer.
πΊ Watch every match on Apple TV: http://apple.co/MLS
The π plays here: https://www.mlssoccer.com/messi/
β‘οΈ Subscribe Now: https://www.youtube.com/c/mls
β‘οΈ Follow us on:
– TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@mls?lang=en
– Instagram: http://instagram.com/mls
– Twitter: https://twitter.com/MLS
– Like us on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/MLS
β‘οΈ Para EspaΓ±ol:
– YouTube EspaΓ±ol: https://www.youtube.com/@MLS-EspaΓ±ol
– Instagram: http://instagram.com/mlses
– Twitter: https://twitter.com/MLSes
– Facebook: facebook.com/espanol.mls
For more information about MLS, go to the league’s official website: http://www.MLSsoccer.com, en espaΓ±ol http://www.MLSes.com
#mls #highlights #goals
source
The thing is if Denky didnβt go down dramatically, it wouldnβt have been given. Even though he was fouled. Ref wouldnβt have called it live and VAR wouldnβt have done anything. So sometimes they have to go down when they are fouled or they wonβt get the call.
Seriously nothing on the foul against Gazdag? He was fouled in the box but the ref gave a free kick outside. Went to VAR and still didnβt give it. Costed them a points too. Even the announcers said it was a pk and couldnβt believe why it was given was a free kick instead
I hope this guy is not a ref
Maybe you need to actually watch the video and the player response to the "push" by Seattle. After 40 years of officiating, I usually note how players respond off each other. If that was a "clear push", the SJ players body would have had a response to the "push". Yet, you see none.The appearence of a push does not necessarily mean it was one.
I used to respect Wiebe's opinion
Within 34 seconds of the video I realize how idiotic Wiebe is and save myself the exhaustion from this hot takes
0:32 You call that a push? Get your eyes checked. What kind of push is it
exactly, the player didnt even move with the push. Handball was the correct
call nothing before it.
Why does FIFA allow so many players in the goal box or even in the penalty box during free kicks? Packing that many players in such a small area is designed to create fouls and injuries. Even when a goal is awarded off a free kick, it seems one or more fouls could be called. And then there is all the injury time with one or more players laid out on the pitch holding their heads or grabbing their backs. Consider this rule change. During free kicks, excepting the goalie, only allow two players from each team in the goal box and only allow two players from each team in the penalty area outside of the goal box.
He was not pushed, dude. He was touched. If you call that in a game, then you're going to be calling a foul every 30 seconds. Who is this guy?
1 – is not a penalty because, yes, his arms are open, but it is part of the natural movement, as the handball rule says, βA player is considered to have made their body unnaturally bigger when the position of their hand/arm is not a consequence of, or justifiable by, the playerβs body movement for that specific situation." His arms being open is completely justifiable considering he was falling.
2 – It's the same case as the first and by rule is not a penalty; again, no one is making their body "unnaturally bigger' without being part of a player's natural body movement.
3 – The hug happens, but it's soft; that kind of thing happens in every corner kick. The player did not fall because of the hug, but because he threw himself into the ground, so he had no real impact, so not a penalty.
4 – Very soft touch; you can argue the t-shirt was pulled, but I would not call it, and I doubt the majority of refs would.
5 – Right decision; the same thing happened in a Libertadores final with a manager called Cuca, same result: red card.
β€β€mls
VAR era: too many soft, soft penalties
These videos really help me as a young referee. Keep up the great work!
Not foul, why refere gif finalty it's not okay for miami,,
Wasit curang
in last 2 weeks i checked last 80 Miami and Messi matches on other chanel with more higlights becose MLS showes only what they want and i find out that 62 times other team was helped more then Miami. 60+ freekicks on Messi not given, 26 yellow cards given to Miami when there wasn't even a faul, 6 red cards given when it should be yellow,time added in the end if Miami was winning by 2 or was loosing or drawing or other team was winning only 3-5 minutes,if Miami was winning only by one goal then time added was 10-15 minutes, 16 penalties not given to Miami,11 offside goals not given where there was no offside and at least 50+ times the game was stoped becose of a faul on Miami player when Miami had the ball and could easy score from counter-attack. untill refferes, comentators,MLS, MLS media, USA media dosn't get better,they will never be even close to top 5 League in the world and they will never again be even close to top 20 country in football… everyone against Messi and Miami when only Messi makes 70% of MLS profit. this profit with good decitions can make new good players in the future,and you all are shiting on him whenewer you can. dissgracefull!!
Why you don't talk about that h???? Btw. Camera angle from last match against cincinati proved the ball was spinning and never hit a goalkeeper and MLS didn't give Messi the goal,like 10+ times before,when they called offside and it wasn't..
Wait till the world cup and see if any ref cares about any of these tugs and pulls in the box. No other league in the world blows the whistle on this stuff. None. This stupidity is turning the MLS into netball IYKYK.
Totally disagree with the MLS instant replay analysis on the Sounders handball. Watch the player movements relative to the lines on the field. . Watch the Sounder player. There is no power behind the contact because it was not really a push. The contact is on the side not the back. Both players are looking at the ball the entire time and the San Jose player misjudges the flight path of the ball. Watch again from 0:30–0:33. The San Jose player moves towards the goal then reverses into the Sounders player. Next, the defender throws his left arm up to head height after turning to find the ball. Pause at 0:36. It is very misleading to imply that only the San Jose player is looking at the ball. They are both very clearly looking at the ball. MLS instant replay really hates the Sounders.
No delay on the last one wtf?
3:15 A fellow Daniel Negreanu fan I see, but cβmon Andrew your takes on contact in the box are room temp IQ. This is ridiculous. Football is a contact sport and the attackers have to show some more strength than a pool noodle
The take on the Sounders game is the worst I've seen in recent memory. So wrong.
0:42
No, that's a handball. Come on.
Not enough of a foul by the Seattle player to warrant a VAR check
Please get rid of that huge freaking banner! It takes up a third of the screen we want to watch the play not the banner.
Love how you ignore the Sounders game that you were at over the weekend, and then lead off this one with the sounders game that was one of the last games of the day.
MLS refs still buy the over acting contact, and the players know it. It gives the game a bad image when phantom fouls are wrongly called that decide who wins or loses. Glad when Messi finally retires, tired of the chronic Miami tsunami the league promotes. I still rate Pele ahead of Messi as the best ever, how many World Cups has Messi helped Argentina win compared to Pele?
If i owned mls or had a stake in it i woukd do the same thing you guys are doing π always something involving inter Miami and messi ππΎ
I can understand the argument on the Kossa Rienzi "push" overturning the penalty but it would still be incredibly harsh. Think the original decision was best
"Hand Ball Rules" and "Penalty Kicks Earned via Dramatic Acting" are the scourge of soccer. It's gotta change! Boo!
Miami: agree
DC: disagree
MLS need to implement a challenge var system for the upcoming shortened season. And then keep it
3:06 well and thatβs a top 2 problem with soccer: if you donβt fall over then it doesnβt get called
As you can see in the "push" it does not affect him whatsoever and he still had several seconds to put his arm down to not hit it with his arm.
ππππππππππ Know wonder Football β½οΈ isn't taken seriously in the USA , with reviews from this narrator shows how far MLS have to caught up to the rest of the world ππππππ .